Net Commercials and Oil & Gold Revisited
Posted by James on November 22nd, 2006
Crude Oil [ http://www.buythebottom.com/wtic.html ]
First of all let’s look at oil. The two charts above are displaying USO (oil ETF) and WTIC (oil). If you notice the count from 1 through 4, the pattern is very similar. This makes perfect sense as USO is supposed to track the price of oil. That is until you get to the low made at 5. Here you can see USO at new lows while WTIC is above its lows. In fact as I am writing this on Monday, USO just made another minor new low, while crude oil is trading above its low at point 5. This could be a result of the fact that next month’s oil contract is rolling in (January vs December). It could also mean that stock-traders are hedging against a further oil decline, as they sell the USO ETF and as a result drive prices to lower lows while crude oil finds support at higher lows.
But what is even more important is the net-commercial position. And what is bothering me somewhat, is that net-commercial position has decreased over the last two weeks by a total of 17 639 contracts. And all this while oil is not yet rallying, in fact it is still sitting near its monthly lows. One reason for this could be that large-traders got a little ahead of themselves, and picked the bottom a little bit early. This raises a yellow flag; however, I would like to see next week’s COT data, for confirmation. Otherwise, two data points do not make a trend.
Personally I remain constructive on oil; and if you think about it from a psychological point of view, the play that worked thus far over the last few months, was to buy stocks and sell oil. The only problem is that once everybody buys stocks and sells oil, there is nobody else left to drive stock-prices higher and oil-prices lower. At those junctures we will have a top in the stock market and a bottom in the oil market. I believe that a bottom in the oil market is fast approaching; I am less sure about a top in the stock market. Some COT data is pointing to at topping pattern (SPX) while other data is pointing towards higher prices still (NDX). With oil however, the cot data overall remains bullish, and in the short-term I would like to see whether commercials will start their buying campaign once again. If they do, the oil setup will be near perfect in terms of risk / reward.
Broad Markets
Russell 2000 [ http://www.buythebottom.com/rut.html ]
Net-commercial position increased by 312 contracts.
S&P 500 [ http://www.buythebottom.com/spx.html ]
Net-commercial position decreased by 16 062 contracts. If this selling pressure continues, this market will be setup for a decline pretty soon.
NASDAQ 100 [ http://www.buythebottom.com/ndx.html ]
Net-commercial position increased by 1 149 contracts. In two out of the last three weeks, both commercials and large-traders were buyers in this market, while small traders were sellers. Although this is bullish, there has been commercial selling in the MINI-Nasdaq not to mention a lot of selling in the S&P 500.
Dow Jones [ http://www.buythebottom.com/indu.html ]
Net-commercial position increased by 775 contracts.
I continue to remain neutral on the stock-market. The trend continues to point up; meanwhile I don’t see a clear signal from the commercial players. Until then, I will continue to pay close attention to these markets to try and gage their future direction as soon as a clearer picture develops.
The VIX or fear index is at very low levels. This implies that there is very little fear amongst investors which normally correlates with rising stock market. Commercials were big sellers of the VIX a few weeks ago. Consequently, the VIX broke down to new lows as the market rallied. So far, the VIX is not yet setup to move up. So I am not anticipating fear/volatility to re-enter this market, just yet. This is telling me that the markets will probably continue to move higher. I plan on adding a VIX-chart to the buythebottom.com website, shortly.
Commodities
Gold [ http://www.buythebottom.com/gold.html ]
Net-commercial position decreased by 9 065 contracts, in fact, over the last three weeks net-commercial position declined rather dramatically by 43 012 contracts. From this selling, I would not be buying gold at these levels. It seems that a correction / consolidation is in order. From a big-picture perspective the trend is up, as long as we continue to trade above $550.
Currencies
US Dollar [ http://www.buythebottom.com/usd.html ]
Net-commercial position increased by 4 168 contracts. The US dollar was setup for a decline just a few weeks ago. And now it is setup for a rally. It is interesting that as commercials sold the dollar they bought oil & gold, and now as they are buying the US dollar they are conversely, selling oil & gold… The US dollar index is setup to rally and if it does, look for the dollar to re-test its reaction-high at approx. 87.25.
More related posts:
Digg it Del.icio.us Reddit Furl BlinkList Newsvine Yahoo MyWeb







November 23rd, 2006 at 3:02 am
Do you mean that you think we are near a bottoming price in oil, or do you think that a major price drop that will make for a bottom is coming and soon?
I might agree with the latter, but I think we have a way to go before we see the bottom in oil prices. Inventories are at all time highs, and markets are trading in contango (the unusual situation where delivery in six months is more expensive than delivery today). Think about how odd this is – when would you pay more for a TV or furniture, or anything else and then wait to get it for six months when you could buy the same thing for less and have it today? You wouldn’t. You would just purchase it today and start enjoying it.
The only reason to do this is that you cannot store the goods today. In other words, too much inventory and not enough storage. I see the oil markets having to start unloading the high inventories that have been building over the past several years. It is becoming too expensive to find a place to keep the oil. At a minimum, inventory has to stop building, which will mean less demand, and lower prices.
Lower prices may also lead to sales of inventories, when people who have purchased inventories at high prices realize that they are faced with significant writedowns in the values of those inventories (and want to get some cash back before prices head lower).